Return to Primary Index
Middle East Struggle Index
National/International Index
Jewish art, Palestinian land
US vetoes UN observers in Palestine
Israeli propaganda creates obstacles to peace over Jerusalem
Ahud Barak compares 9/11 WTC deaths of 3000 to the 400 Jews killed in 34 years by Palestinians
Israel provokes Hamas violence
United Nations Resolution 242: demands Israel withdraw from land seized in 1967 War
The US double standard for terrorism in Palestine
Demos Pres Carter defends Palestinian Human Rights; Rep Waxman favors Israel
Mandela defends Barghouti
Zionism distorts US politics by Congressman Paul Findley
The Myth of the "Generous Offer" that ended the Oslo Peace Process
Bush Calls For Israeli Annexation of West Bank Settlements

Oops! Powell takes back Bush's Foreign Policy Gaff - or does he?

April 17, 2004

President Bush, speaking to the press after his meeting with Ariel Sharon on Wednesday (4/14), cited "new realities" and said that, because things have changed over the past decades, Israel will permanently keep several major settlements in the occupied West Bank. This statement was the first pronouncement of a precedent-setting policy reversal on the eventual outcome of the struggle over the occupied territories. This change of US long-standing policy has caused an uproar around the world.

For the past 37 years, the US has joined with the international community and the UN in demanding the lands seized in the 1967 war be returned to control of the Palestine inhabitants. UN Security Council Resolutions 242 and 338 were agreed to by the US. The details of a peace agreement between the Palestinians and Israel were to be settled in final status talks according to the "Roadmap" drawn up by the "Quartet" (the US, Russia, the UN, and the European Union), Bush's latest pronouncement tears up the roadmap.

However, according to the article below, Secretary of State Colin Powell and other White House spokesmen are insisting Bush really didn't destroy nearly four decades of policy. The spin is that Bush's committment to Sharon doesn't actually prejudge the outcome of the final status talks. Somehow we all just got confused. Sure we did! Powell and the White House staff should follow Bush around with the policy equivalent of the pooper scooper that we take when walking our dogs.

Powell Aims to Calm Furor Over Israel Plan

By BARRY SCHWEID AP Diplomatic Writer


Secretary of State Colin Powell led a diplomatic offensive Thursday to placate Arab leaders outraged by President Bush's support for Jewish settlements on the West Bank and opposition to Palestinian refugees returning to Israel.

Powell insisted in interviews and telephone calls that Bush's meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon produced positive results for the Palestinians and their statehood aspirations.

For the first time in 37 years, Powell said, Israeli settlements are being removed and the property used to benefit the Palestinian people.

"The president did not endorse any particular outcome," Powell said at a State Department news conference. "He did not endorse any settlements yesterday."

Nor, Powell said, did Bush take positions different from those of previous administrations that "modifications, adjustments, changes will be required" in the borders Israel held before capturing the West Bank and Gaza in the 1967 Mideast war.

"Everybody knows that," Powell said, although he acknowledged that "we know this is a very emotional issue for all people in the region, on both sides."

In an interview with the Canadian Broadcasting Corp., Powell said the settlements Israel was giving up in Gaza "will benefit the Palestinian people who live in Gaza."

Israel also is giving up four settlement son the West Bank, and "this is the beginning of a process," Powell said.

But the Palestinian prime minister, Ahmed Qureia, said after meeting with Yasser Arafat that he was considering resigning. He said Bush had undermined the negotiating process.

In New York, British Prime Minister Tony Blair said the Israeli decision could be the basis for progress. "If it is the case that the Israelis, albeit unilateraly, disengage from a significant part of the West Bank and from the Gaza, that is quite a big change," Blair said a news conference with U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan.

Blair was to meet with Bush in Washington Friday.

Annan said that such issues as borders and refugees should be decided in negotiations. Earlier, a U.N. spokeswoman said the negotiations should be based on U.N. Security Council resolutions.

Adopted in 1967 and 1973, the resolutions call on Israel to withdraw from territory captured from the Arabs in two Mideast wars.

Referring to Israel and the Palestinians, spokeswoman Marie Okabe said Annan "strongly believes that they should refrain from taking any steps that would prejudice or pre-empt the outcome of such talks."

What outraged the Arabs were statements Wednesday by Bush after a White House meeting with Sharon.

The president, citing "new realities," endorsed Israel's retention of some population centers and settlements on the West Bank as part of a final agreement with the Palestinians.

He repeated his promise to try to help establish a Palestinian state by next year but said Palestinians who claim their families were exiled during Israel's founding 56 years ago should be resettled in the Palestinian state, not Israel.

That statement supported Israel's contention that the country's Jewish identity could be erased if tens of thousands of Palestinians were added to the 1 million Israeli Arabs already there.

"Frankly," Powell told CBC, "those refugees should return to the new state of Palestine, which is what it was created for, not Israel."

However, Powell said, "ultimately it is for the two parties to work this out among themselves, not for the United States to dictate."

The State Department spokesman, Richard Boucher, said meanwhile that "there is no change in U.S. policy on settlements."

What changed, Boucher said, was that Sharon was willing to withdraw from settlements and from Gaza. "We will work with the Israelis, we will work with others, we will work with the Palestinians to make this a reality and make it really happen," he said.

Boucher said Palestinian Foreign Minister Nabil Shaath was expected to visit Washington next week. Shaath is to meet with Powell and with Condoleezza Rice, Bush's national security adviser.

Powell spoke by telephone to Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, Qureia, Annan, King Abdullah II of Jordan and Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Maher.