Return to Primary Index
Environment & Health Index
Middle East Struggle Index
National/International Index
US environmentalists called "Terrorists"
Even The Nation covers for Israel
Israel holds hostages
Israel's surrogate militia bombs Lebanese school
NPR anti-Arab racism
Double standard in NPR coverage of Middle East struggle
Jewish art, Palestinian land
US media finds Jews suffer, Palestinians blamed
Indefadah II
US vetoes UN observers in Palestine
Israeli propaganda creates obstacles to peace over Jerusalem
The World Rejects US Bullying and Racism
The Question "Why do militant Muslims hate us?" yields more spin than answers
Collateral Damage in Afganistan
Ahud Barak compares 9/11 WTC deaths of 3000 to the 400 Jews killed in 34 years by Palestinians
Israel's terrorist bomb kills five Palestinian chlidren
Israel provokes Hamas violence
United Nations Resolution 242: demands Israel withdraw from land seized in 1967 War

National Public Radio under attack from US Jews, retracts coverage of Israeli Settlers' violence against Palestinians

January 14, 2002

Updated 01/24/02

Updated 01/26/02

Updated 01/30/02

US Jews who have waged an organized campaign to influence NPR's coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict have succeeded in enforcing at least one of their demands by withholding promised donations of thousands of dollars to NPR affiliate stations ( On The Media, NPR, 12/22/01 ). On Weekend Morning Edition, 1/12/01, host Scott Simon apologized for a Nov., 2001, statement attributing to Jewish settlers the shooting to death of an 18-year-old Palestinian girl.

After the feature segment about Jews from the Israeli peace activist movement helping Palestinians pick olives was aired, it became a centerpiece in the Jewish organization CAMERA's ( Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America ) campaign to portray the US media, and particularly NPR, as biased against Israel. Now the original description of the shooting has been retracted and replaced by an ambiguous statement which includes the possibility that Israeli Army soldiers may have killed the girl. NPR host Simon apologized for the possible error.

To some of us, the difference between these descriptions may appear slight, and indeed the retraction reflects the nit-picking quality of the CAMERA objections. Much of the "factual" basis for CAMERA objections to US media coverage depends on statistical analysis of the number of words spoken in reports of events in Middle East which CAMERA perceives as favorable to Israel compared to the words considered less than supportive of the organization's pro-Israeli spins.

Pending a more complete rebuttal of the CAMERA charges, including much evidence of precisely the opposite bias, we suggest CAMERA and NPR and Scott Simon reflect on the front-page commentary,
A Dangerous Liquidation, by Alex Fishman which recently appeared in the leading circulation Israeli newspaper Yediot Aharonot, Nov. 25, 2001.

The Fishman statement is just one example of the considerably more open skepticism and critical analysis of official Israeli motives and policies, routine in the Israeli media, than can ever be found on NPR or in the mainstream US press.

Briefly, the Fishman commentary contains direct accusations of a deliberate provocation by Israel, authorized by top Israeli officials, calculated to incite Palestinian suicide attacks on Israelis, with the intent of frustrating the December peace mission by US General Anthony Zinni and putting the blame on the Palestinians.

The provocation charged is the Nov. 22, 2001, assassination of Mahmud Abu Hunud, senior Hamas leader, by Israeli helicopter gunships. The Fishman article is particularly striking for several reasons: the paper hitherto approved of the Israeli government's policy of assassinating Palestinians deemed to be terrorists, and on numerous occasions in the past year news and commentaries were published with an often crude anti-Palestinian slant.

In contrast, the Fishman statement was given a very conspicuous place, in a box on the paper's front page. The author, Alex Fishman, is Yediot's security commentator, and is far from dovish and is known to have close contacts in the army and the security services. The accusation of deliberate provocation is unequivocal in the following exerpt:

Whoever gave a green light to this act of liquidation knew full well that he is thereby shattering in one blow the gentleman's agreement between Hamas and the Palestinian Authority; under that agreement, Hamas was to avoid in the near future suicide bombings inside the Green Line. ....

This understanding was, however, shattered by the assassination. Whoever decided upon the liquidation of Abu Hunud knew in advance that that would be the price. The subject was extensively discussed both by Israel's military echelon and its political one, before it was decided to carry out the liquidation.

The Israeli plan was successful. Reprisal suicide bombings killed over two dozen Israelis and Zinni left without progress toward a truce. Palestinians were blamed. A month-long wave of Israeli "reprisals" against Palestinians followed, invasions, killings, demolition of homes, total confinement and bans on travel.

The left-leaning but mainstream Israeli paper Haaretz includes many other examples of the criticism of Israel's occupation and violence against the Palestinians. These examples from the Israeli media, contrasted with the US media, contradict the CAMERA claims of a pro-Palestinian bias in US media; in fact, the exact opposite is the case. Among the hundreds of examples, we offer the following specific items :

  1. Haaretz, Thursday, April 19, 2001, "Sderot's potholes versus their ruined land," by Danny Rubinstein
  2. Haaretz Daily News, Wednesday, July 8, 1998, "The humiliation caused by a sealed-off road" by Amira Hass
  3. Haaretz01/20/02, "Red line, Green Line, black flag," by Yigal Shochat, http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=118432&sw=Yigal+Shochat
  4. Haaretz, Monday, January 21, 2002, Shvat 8, 5762 Israel Time:04:55(GMT+2), The war against the unborn: How did we get to the point where Israeli soldiers are preventing women in labor from reaching a hospital? By Gideon Levy http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=118434&contrassID=2
  5. Haaretz, Thursday, January 24, 2002, As war cries ring out, U.S. silence may signal rare free hand for Israeli military moves By Bradley Burston ; The Bush Administration OK's Sharon Assassinations of Palestinian suspects http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=120966&displayTyp eCd=1&sideCd=1&contrassID=2
  6. Haaretz Friday, January 25, 2002, The Bulldozer's last chance By Yoel Marcus http://www.haaretz.co.il/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=121581&contrassID=2& subContrassID=4&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y&itemNo=121581
    Sharon is being beaten up in the Israeli press
  7. Haaretz Friday, January 25, 2002, Tell the truth, Shimon By Gideon Levy http://www.haaretz.co.il/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=120930&contrassID=2& subContrassID=14&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y
    Gideon Levy, former staffer for Shimon Perez, charges the Israeli Foreign Minister and Nobel Laureate that it is his last chance to denounce the war crimes and provocations of the Sharon Government.
  8. Jerusalem Post JERUSALEM (January 25, 2002) Shin Bet bill nears final readings By Dan Izenberg
    http://www.jpost.com/Editions/2002/01/25/News/News.42312.html
    The Jerusalem Post reports controversy over a proposed Israeli law explicitly authorizing the "use of moderate physical pressure," by the Israeli Secret and Military Police. The article is out front that the subject being debated is torture of suspected Palestinian militants. The article further acknowledges that the practice of torture by Israel is routine, but not yet encoded into law.
  9. Haaretz (Jan 30,2002) The smile of policeman Agadi By Abdel Rahman al-Ahmed
    http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=123485&contrassID=2&subContrassID=11&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y&itemNo=123485
    This article is by a victim of Israeli torture who calls for peace, not revenge. American taxes pay to support the torture, but we will never read such information in the US press.
  10. Haaretz (Jan. 30, 2002) Legal targets By Amira Hass
    http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=123465&contrassID=2&subContrassID=4&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y&itemNo=123465 This article quotes from the mainstream Israeli Yedioth Ahronoth's weekend supplement (Jan. 25, 2002, http://www.ynet.co.il/home/ , Hebrew only): "Once a sniper from one of the outposts hit a young boy at a distance of 150 meters," Shuki Sadeh, an Israel Defense Forces reservist officer, told Haim Tal (Yedioth Ahronoth). The article goes on to review Ahronoth interviews with IDF soldiers who have publicly refused to serve in Occupied Palestine. Amira Haas quotes the military resisters' charges that IDF policies against killing Palestinian children who pose no threat are a sham. The quotes make it clear that flagrant murder is never prosecuted.

It is the intention of The Don Quixote Society Website to add to this list of examples and update this page as time permits. Contributions (and attempts at rebuttal) will be considered.